James Wilder Jr. was not trying to be his harshest critic Wednesday.
But with the Argos season slipping in the wrong direction and with a pivotal game against Ottawa at BMO Field on Thursday night, the subject of the running back’s performance through six games came up.
And Wilder is not impressed with his performance.
Get game analysis, stats, and more daily at 3pm
Here’s exactly what you’ll get.
- ✓ Canadian football's biggest stories
- ✓ Smart game analysis
- ✓ Every CFL transaction covered with exclusive insight
“Not there yet, no way,” Wilder said Wednesday.
“I think I have two games (out of six) over 125 yards, and at the running back position in this league, and going into our seventh game, that’s not going to cut it. It’s not consistent enough. I’ve had sparks in games, then there’s been games where I have negative yardage. That’s not where I want to be, that’s not where I need to be … it’s not close to the goals I was raving about in the off-season.”
Wilder is fifth in rushing yards in the CFL with 301 yards. Only four backs have more than 400 yards — led by Winnipeg’s Andrew Harris with 638 — and it is a group the defending rookie of the year should be in.
Wilder was among the CFL leaders a year ago in combined yards, and he’s 10th this year with 581. He also has three of the Argos’ nine offensive touchdowns this season.
The problem for the Argos is those nine majors reflect a team that has lost five of six games while looking far too inconsistent.
Toronto’s offence is at or near the bottom in terms of touchdowns, offensive points, net offence, and passing touchdowns. Combine that with a frustrating turnover rate, penalties, and a defence that has mirrored the offence in terms of failing to find itself, and the Argos are in crisis mode right now.
“We’ve been shooting ourselves in the foot, penalties, turnovers, its been a bit of a comedy of errors …,” offensive lineman Chris Van Zeyl said.
“It’s not one guy hurting us through a game, it’s a culmination of everyone taking their turns. You can see how good we can be, but there’s been (inconsistencies) … I think consistency is a good word for us right now, we need to be more consistent. When we find it, we’ll be in a good place.”
The Argos were the better yardage team against Winnipeg last week, but they lost in large part because of seven turnovers.
Wilder, like Van Zeyl, sees Thursday’s game against Ottawa as a must-win game, or as close to one there is at this time of the season.
The Redblacks, the leaders in the CFL East, arguably possess the best group of defensive backs and linemen in the East. They will pose a huge challenge for Wilder, Van Zeyl and the rest of the Argos offence, especially with McLeod Bethel-Thompson making his season debut at quarterback.
“We don’t look at (Bethel-Thompson) as a new quarterback, he’s been around here for a year and a half, and he’s been around football for a long time,” Van Zeyl said.
The 30-year-old Bethel-Thompson, who has spent time with nine other pro teams, said the Argos are chalk full of top-shelf players and it is his goal to “make their day a little smoother.”
The San Francisco native says he’s as calm and collected as the rest of his teammates appear to be, regardless of what the standings say.
“I’ve been cut 11 or 12 times from NFL teams, signed and cut,” Bethel-Thompson said. “It takes a level of insanity and obsession to keep at it. I think I’m insane enough to still be here.”
Sign up for the 3DownNation daily newsletter
B.C. Lions
3DownNation CFL power rankings:
Calgary Stampeders
Calgary Stampeders release Montréal product Kaylyn St-Cyr, nine others
Saskatchewan Roughriders
Jack Coan, Trevor Harris compete to outwork each other with Saskatchewan Roughriders
Saskatchewan Roughriders
Saskatchewan Roughriders sign undrafted Canadian DB Trae Tomlinson
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
Mike O’Shea defends Willie Jefferson’s declining sack numbers
Hamilton Tiger-Cats
Matthew Shiltz inks one-day contract to retire with Hamilton Tiger-Cats
Toronto Argonauts
Toronto Argonauts cut incumbent starter Spencer Brown, nine others
Toronto Argonauts
Toronto Argonauts sign Alex Teubner after release from B.C.
Ottawa Redblacks
Ottawa Sooners building star-studded CFL coaching staff in CJFL
Montreal Alouettes
Veteran CFL quarterback Dustin Crum chose Montreal Alouettes over B.C. Lions
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
The CFL’s highest-paid running backs and fullbacks in 2026
B.C. Lions
The CFL’s highest-paid receivers in 2026
Edmonton Elks
The CFL’s highest-paid offensive linemen in 2026
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
Five position battles to watch in Winnipeg Blue Bombers training camp
Toronto Argonauts
Syracuse, Wake Forest to play at BMO Field in Toronto in 2027
B.C. Lions
The CFL’s 30 highest-paid players for 2026
Edmonton Elks
The CFL’s highest-paid defensive backs in 2026
Calgary Stampeders
Vernon Adams Jr. signs contract extension with Calgary Stampeders
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
CFL rookie, training camp vet Taylor Elgersma ready to battle for Winnipeg Blue Bombers
Toronto Argonauts
Toronto Argonauts release QB Max Duggan
Ottawa Redblacks
Ottawa Redblacks 2026 CFL training camp primer (offence)
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
Brady Oliveira wants to play 10 CFL seasons, retire as a Winnipeg Blue Bomber
Saskatchewan Roughriders
Position battles to watch in Saskatchewan Roughriders 2026 CFL training camp
Ottawa Redblacks
The CFL’s highest-paid linebackers in 2026
Saskatchewan Roughriders
Saskatchewan Roughriders sign Regina native Ryder Varga